The use of the image of a deceased personality,
especially one whose estate is administered in the USA, in any
commercial, advertising, endorsement or merchandising situation is
protected by various laws which dictate that, in most countries of the
world, the estate or legal representative of any deceased person,
should have previously approved the use of that image, especially if
the image has been modified or altered in any way.
Even if the image is used in religious or
charitable advertising, permission from the estate must first be
obtained. To use such an image (especially of a deceased Hollywood
star) in a commercial situation without first obtaining permission is
highly likely to render the advertiser and the publisher
or broadcaster liable to prosecution and payment of substantial
damages. (Obviously, this does not apply if images are used in a non-commercial
or editorial manner). This is also quite separate from the need to
obtain permission for the use of any image from the copyright owner.
However, there are exceptions. In the United
Kingdom it is permissible to use the image of a deceased ‘British’
personality without first obtaining permission from anyone, except the
copyright owner and provided the image does not contravene the
uniquely British law of ‘passing-off’. For example, misleadingly
implying that a deceased person may have used a particular product or
service during his or her life, unless it can be proven that they
actually did so. * (See ‘Our View’ below).
Strictly speaking, it is also possible to use the
image of a deceased foreign personality (not of EU birth or residence)
in a commercial situation within the United Kingdom, provided
permission has been granted by the copyright owner, but without
obtaining permission from the estate. PROVIDED use is strictly limited
to within the United Kingdom. However, this can be dangerous and
is highly inadvisable for many reasons. ‘Dead Famous’ will advise
clients on this.
Before approaching the estate of any deceased
celebrity with a proposal for the use of an image (photograph, film,
video etc.) in a commercial or advertising situation, as has been
stated, it will first be necessary to obtain permission (or an option)
for the use of the image from the copyright owner. Unless the
advertiser is the copyright owner (as in the case of a piece of
original advertising artwork) in which case confirmation may be
required.
The copyright owner will usually be a photographer,
film company, picture library or archive. It is NOT normally the
estate, which rarely own copyright material. Substantial fees are
often payable to copyright owners.
The estate, or legal representatives, will not
usually grant permission for the use of an image unless the copyright
owner has already given written approval, especially if the image is
to be modified or digitally altered in any way. However, copyright
owners usually defer permission until the estate has given written
approval, as they are well aware of the legal penalties involved. This
is a classic ‘Catch 22’ situation.
‘Dead Famous’ is able to advise clients on
where to obtain copyright material and how to avoid this problem.
Lawyers for the estates will then request a large
amount of information for which ‘Dead Famous’ has devised a number
of straightforward forms for our clients to complete. A draft contract
is required at this point, the legal costs of which must be borne by
the client.
Having negotiated many such contracts, ‘Dead
Famous’ is uniquely placed to advise clients on the most persuasive
form in which to present their proposal, which is most likely to
receive prompt approval. ‘Dead Famous’ also have many draft
contracts that have been pre-approved and used many times in similar
situations, thus saving our clients many thousands of pounds in legal
fees.
Negotiations with the estates, can be lengthy and
costly, with no guarantee of success, unless properly advised by
experts. ‘Dead Famous’ know the deadlines to which advertising
agencies are obliged to work and will always strive to accommodate our
clients needs.
© Dead Famous Ltd. 2000
LEGAL NOTE: This information is published gratis
and is the view of Dead Famous Ltd. whose interpretation must not be
relied upon in a court of law. Clients are advised to obtain
independent legal advice before entering into any contract concerning
the use of a copyright image of a deceased celebrity. Dead Famous Ltd.
have a selection of specialist lawyers who can advise clients on all
aspects of international copyright and publishing law.